Open everyday 7am–5pm (Summer Only)

696 Montauk Hwy
⮑ Access through the Cynthia Rowley store
New York, NY 11954

⮑ From 7am–10am
Use alternate access in the back
20 S. Elmwood Ave

  •

    Getting there

  •

    Clues everywhere

  •

    The Shack

  •

    Enjoy

⮑ Map


⮑ Menu

MONTAUK
DNFA
SUMMER 2026

COFFEE

Espresso

5

 

Cappuccino

7

 

Cold Brew

7.5

 

Iced Latte

8

MATCHA

Iced Matcha Latte

8

 

Strawberry Matcha Latte

9
Strawberry Oat Milk - Matcha

 

Yuzu Sundown

9.5
Yuzu Soda - Matcha - Orange Syrup

 

Coconut Water Matcha

8
Coconut Water - Matcha

SPECIALTY

Dark Shore

9.5
Cold Brew - Silky Vanilla Cold Foam

 

Birch Water Americano

9
Iced Birch Water - Espresso

 

Pistachio Iced Latte

9
Pistachio Oat Milk - Espresso

 

Espresso Tonic

9
Espresso - San Bitter Soda

 

Pink Brazilian Lemonade

8
Lime - Strawberry

SODAS

Cola, Ginger, Orange

6.5
MONTAUK
DNFA
MARKET

DNFA

Alligator Cap

49

 

Alligator Tote

38

 

Gym Bag - Black

48

 

Tank Top

24

COFFEE BAGS

Solaris

25

 

Pink Bourbon

29

SNACKS

Mango Bars

5

 

Lenka Bars

6.5

 

Rind Dry Fruits

8

 

Black Salt Chips

6

 

Little Mel's Dates

6

 

Italian Biscotti

3

 

Ta-Ral-Li

9

 

Rosemary Nuts

11

SKIN CARE

Freaks Sunscreen

28

 

Bask Sunscreen

24

 

Utu Face Sunscreen

24

 

Korres Lip Balm

19

 

Hand Balm

48
NEWYORKINA X
DNFA
ICE CREAM

POPSICLES

Pink Limeade

6.5

 

Pineapple Mint

6.5

 

Passion Fruit

6.5

 

Mango Raspberry

6.5

 

Mango Chile

6.5

 

Coconut

6.5

 

Oishii Koyo

6.5

 

Chocolate

6.5

 

Horchata

6.5

SANDWICHES

Babka Vanilla

8.5

 

Choc. Chip Horchata

8.5

  • Do Not Feed Alligators Montauk is a seasonal specialty coffee shop located at 696 Montauk Highway. During the summer season we serve espresso, rare single-origin coffees, matcha, and seasonal drinks in a relaxed East End setting near the beach.

⮑ All DNFA Locations


PP-DEBUG: Current path: /pages/montauk